At this point, re-signing Sweat should absolutely be "let's wait and see". If he doesnt pull a contract year Daron Payne type season, why are you dropping top dollar on Sweat? He's bern good, not great. Cuz remember Payne was basically outta here when last season started. I feel like Sweat is in a similar situation.
What I'm afraid of is the situation with Young will make us less critical of whether Sweat should come back. Like, we'll feel we cant let them both walk at the same time.
And for the record, I'm not against Sweat coming back, he's been a good player. But I think as an edge rusher, he'll command more than I would be willing to pay for what he's done.