Jump to content
Washington Football Team Logo
Extremeskins

A Dozen Current QBs Better Than Romo...


tr1

Recommended Posts

Romo sits to pee is also about to be the first player in history to post 4 seasons of 90+ rating to start a career and I believe only the 3rd to ever post 4 consecutive seasons of a 90+ rating.

Too bad it's not the start of his career. He entered the league in 2003 and is almost 30.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dude, that argument is so weak. Arguing wins when comparing two players? Come on.

This is the ultimate team game. You can't say that Eli beat Romo sits to pee. The Giants beat the Cowboys.

Laughable argument.

It's not that weak, considering Romo sits to pee has a better offensive line, better tight ends, better running backs.

And in their first meeting, Romo sits to pee's 3 interceptions pretty much lost them the game, and Manning's near flawless game pretty much won them the game in the end.

And if that's the difference between the Giants making the playoffs instead of Dallas...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not that weak, considering Romo sits to pee has a better offensive line, better tight ends, better running backs.

And in their first meeting, Romo sits to pee's 3 interceptions pretty much lost them the game, and Manning's near flawless game pretty much won them the game in the end.

And if that's the difference between the Giants making the playoffs instead of Dallas...

what about Romo sits to pee's monster game in the second meeting? they still lost. it's an absolutely horrible argument. you can't get much worse.

it was amazing how eli stopped the cowboys running game flat.

:hysterical:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not that weak, considering Romo sits to pee has a better offensive line, better tight ends, better running backs.

And in their first meeting, Romo sits to pee's 3 interceptions pretty much lost them the game, and Manning's near flawless game pretty much won them the game in the end.

And if that's the difference between the Giants making the playoffs instead of Dallas...

You conveniently forgot Romo sits to pee's monster game in the second matchup. The Cowboys still lost.

This is not a game of one on one matchups in any way. Weak, weak argument.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If 41-55, 392 yards, 3 TDs, 0 INTs on the road is not a monster game, you're watching the wrong sport pal.
Romo sits to pee completed a bunch of short passes. Wow. His team scored 17 menaningful points on the worst Giants defense I have ever seen. Over the last 9 games, they have given up more points than any other Giants D has in a 9-game stretch in over 40 years.

A monster game is what Drew Brees had against the Giants or Big Ben had against the Packers or Tony Romo sits to pee had against the Giants in week 1 of 2007. 17 non-garbage time points against a truly awful Giants defense is a middling performance at best.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You conveniently forgot Romo sits to pee's monster game in the second matchup. The Cowboys still lost.

This is not a game of one on one matchups in any way. Weak, weak argument.

Romo sits to pee had an excellent game at the meadowlands, but that doesn't discount the fact that his awful game in week 2 was the difference between a win and a loss against a division opponent. And if the Giants make the playoffs instead of the Cowboys, you can look back at that home loss and wonder why the Cowboys lost that game, and why the Giants won.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Romo sits to pee completed a bunch of short passes. Wow. His team scored 17 menaningful points on the worst Giants defense I have ever seen. Over the last 9 games, they have given up more points than any other Giants D has in a 9-game stretch in over 40 years.

A monster game is what Drew Brees had against the Giants or Big Ben had against the Packers or Tony Romo sits to pee had against the Giants in week 1 of 2007. 17 non-garbage time points against a truly awful Giants defense is a middling performance at best.

oh boy. 55 attempts and 392 yards is OVER eli manning's average per pass for his career. this is the only year that has been higher. yikes.

doesn't dallas have some of the worst cb's in the league? everyone keeps saying that. why is it so impressive for eli, but not Romo sits to pee? you're clueless.

Romo sits to pee had an excellent game at the meadowlands, but that doesn't discount the fact that his awful game in week 2 was the difference between a win and a loss against a division opponent. And if the Giants make the playoffs instead of the Cowboys, you can look back at that home loss and wonder why the Cowboys lost that game, and why the Giants won.

he has had one bad game this year. ONE. he has had 3 below average and the rest were incredible. you can look at EVERY qb and find a bad game. if you even watched that game you would have known that 2 int's were extreme flukes off of players heels etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

oh boy. 55 attempts and 392 yards is OVER eli manning's average per pass for his career. this is the only year that has been higher. yikes.
I don't see how that's relevant. Eli's ypa are the result of him completing 57% of his passes. Against the Giants, Romo sits to pee completed 75% of his passes. But they were short passes that lead with minimal production, so the Cowboys only scored 17 meaningful points against an awful Giants defense.
doesn't dallas have some of the worst cb's in the league? everyone keeps saying that. why is it so impressive for eli, but not Romo sits to pee? you're clueless.
The Cowboys have the #1 D in the NFC. They just have no answer for Eli, which is why at times it looks like they have the worst cb's in the league.
he has had one bad game this year. ONE. he has had 3 below average and the rest were incredible. you can look at EVERY qb and find a bad game. if you even watched that game you would have known that 2 int's were extreme flukes off of players heels etc.
If you'd watched the game you would have realized only one of the int's came on an unlikely play. And even that one was the result of a terrible pass by Romo sits to pee.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't see how that's relevant. Eli's ypa are the result of him completing 57% of his passes. Against the Giants, Romo sits to pee completed 75% of his passes. But they were short passes that lead with minimal production, so the Cowboys only scored 17 meaningful points against an awful Giants defense.

The Cowboys have the #1 D in the NFC. They just have no answer for Eli, which is why at times it looks like they have the worst cb's in the league.

If you'd watched the game you would have realized only one of the int's came on an unlikely play. And even that one was the result of a terrible pass by Romo sits to pee.

Come on, man. Put the bias aside for a second and have a logical discussion. Your arguments are just blind hatred and grasping for straws.

Have fun grinding your teeth as Romo sits to pee continues to impress.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Brady

2. Peyton

3. Big Ben

4. Brees

5. Rivers

6. Palmer

7. Cutler

8. McNabb

9. Eli

10. Warner

11. Rodgers

12. Campbell

If Flacco had another year under his belt, he'd be in the list.

1. Brady

2. Peyton

3. Big Ben

4. Brees

5. Rivers

6. Palmer - lol

7. Cutler - lol

8. McNabb

9. Eli - lol

10. Warner

11. Rodgers

12. Campbell - lol

nice list, tr1.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Romo sits to pee Just Set an All-Time Record His updated passer rating is 97.0 after 15 games, so he has wrapped up his 4th consecutive season of 90+

2006 95.1

2007 97.4

2008 91.4

2009 97.0 (so far)

In other words, AWESOME THREAD!!!!!!!!!!

Um, Manning has 7 in a row...what record?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...