Jump to content
Washington Football Team Logo
Extremeskins

What would it take for you to say Campbell is good?


Skins_Win_Again

What do you think of the new site?  

63 members have voted

  1. 1. What do you think of the new site?

    • Amazing
      30
    • Cool
      24
    • Could be better
      5
    • A letdown
      5

This poll is closed to new votes


Recommended Posts

Wanna bet?

View Poll Results: What does Jason have to accomplish

4000+ yards

Mister Happy, Rdskn4Lyf21

3 6.12%

25+ touchdowns

airs0ft3r, daveakl, DeccanSkins, JMSSMJ7, JuicyJ, Mister Happy, Rdskn4Lyf21, Snagletooth, Stophovr6, texasthunder

17 34.69%

Play-offs

#99QBKiller, AKM311, Dick Edds, GibbsFactor, HLF, JuicyJ, Mister Happy, peanut0862, prufRock, Rdskn4Lyf21, Skins-Canes-Mounties, SkinsMaster88, Skins_Win_Again, SteveFromYellowstone, vnmenon1

19 38.78%

Superbowl Appearance

1972FAN, MEANDWARF, Mister Happy, Rdskn4Lyf21

4 8.16%

Pro Bowl

1972FAN, daveakl, Mister Happy, Rdskn4Lyf21, RedskinWarship, SteveFromYellowstone

8 16.33%

Stop making excuses, he's not good and won't ever be

myzhi, spjunkies, SteveFromYellowstone

4 8.16%

He's already good. Everything is blamed on him and the decaying o-line is ignored

airs0ft3r, darrelgreenie, gutlead74, JuicyJ, Justin in NoCal, Micheal Westbrook, mistertim, onnie007, Santana_Fan, Skins_Win_Again, STBonecrusher21

12 24.49%

Yeah you can vote for other things then just one idea.. you cant keep voting for the same option over and over though. :chair:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good lord. :doh:

What did Sanchez do to prove he is the Golden boy? Those 16 games at USC made it so obvious, right?

I was thinking the same thing until i re-watched the Rose Bowl game...:)

I'm not saying one game proves that you are the next Montana, but I don't recall the last time Campbell threw for 413 yards and 4 td's. Penn State isn't a slouch defense either.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was thinking the same thing until i re-watched the Rose Bowl game...:)

I'm not saying one game proves that you are the next Montana, but I don't recall the last time Campbell threw for 413 yards and 4 td's. Penn State isn't a slouch defense either.

With only a month to prepare for a very basic defense and an athletically superior supporting cast..........WOW!!!! i am sold.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

By the way, just so you guys know exactly what it means to win a game with your arm:

When the opposing team takes away your run game and you HAVE to pass because you are down a score or two, and the QB HAS to throw it, the other team knows it, and you still win the game.

When brady, manning, brees, etc are down more than two scores in any game, you know they always have a chance to come back in the game because of their elite throwing abilities. With Campbell behind center the other team would shut down the run and after that the Skins were DONE. No coming back, no heroics from the QB.

THAT's winning the game with your arm.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well then. Why don't you just send a nice long email telling whoever made ES that they're a retard for suggesting such a crime of making this poll available.

You guys are too easy, I say something is "IMO = In My Opinion" and you are talking about retards and crimes? That's so funny it's sad. It's just an opinion get over it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its not about stats, its what he does on the field. He needs to stop staring down receivers. He needs to make faster decisions. He may go through his progressions, but only when he has a day and a half back there. I think despite his low interception ratio this last year, he struggles with accuracy and ball placement.

I do think he will improve from last year, but as to how much will determine whether we should drive on with him or not. Sounds like we may not be going to anyways....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

FTR, I would never say that Campbell will never be good. But I have no problem saying that he hasn't been good. That he's been, in fact, pretty bad in his time as a starter.

And of course, as a Redskin fan, I hope he (or whoever our QB is) DOES get good. So I'm rooting for him. And of course he seems like a great guy and a class act- who wouldn't want to see him "get it"? But time is running out I'm afraid. The window isn't closed but it is awfully close.

now- as to the thread question- I'll refer to the Supreme Court's definition of porn. That is, I'll know it when I see it. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

By the way, just so you guys know exactly what it means to win a game with your arm:

When the opposing team takes away your run game and you HAVE to pass because you are down a score or two, and the QB HAS to throw it, the other team knows it, and you still win the game.

When brady, manning, brees, etc are down more than two scores in any game, you know they always have a chance to come back in the game because of their elite throwing abilities. With Campbell behind center the other team would shut down the run and after that the Skins were DONE. No coming back, no heroics from the QB.

THAT's winning the game with your arm.

great, so when someone refutes your argument (that he's never won a game with his arm), you redefine what it means to do that so it's COMPLETELY INTANGIBLE and therefore irrefutable.

well done, sir. basically, what you're saying is that you want a qb that gives you a certain "vibe" when he's playing. good luck with that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Um, then post what your choice is. Kinda like what I did (just 20 TD's.)

I believe he is a good #2 QB and will be in the league for a while like Ferrotte. If he gets in with the Jets and is not expected to win games just keep them close so the D can do it's thing (like the Ravens do) then he might get to the playoffs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He's the epitome of average which at the pro level could be considered good. He is good, he's just not above average good or even in that second tier of good to almost-great qb's.

There's Peyton, Brady, and Big Ben

Then there's Palmer, Eli, Warner, McNabb, Cutler, Brees (no specific order)

Then there's the Campbell teir of good qb's

Then there's the crappy qb's that get tossed around the league or tossed out of it.

He's good alright.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

great, so when someone refutes your argument (that he's never won a game with his arm), you redefine what it means to do that so it's COMPLETELY INTANGIBLE and therefore irrefutable.

well done, sir. basically, what you're saying is that you want a qb that gives you a certain "vibe" when he's playing. good luck with that.

No, you obviously can't read or are having a hard time understanding.

When has he ever done well when the running game shuts down?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...