I agree. And I really don't like the shooting at the tires. If I were king, I'd charge them with wreck less discharge or something. Not a crazy penalty but enough to send a message. $1000 fine or something.
All that said, I am fine with a few guys calling the police and surrounding the guy until police get there. Now if the thief endangers their lives attempting to flee, then game on. But aim for center mass. And a gun should never be pulled until you have already decided deadly force is needed. Pulling a gun as a threat or warning is not right.