mac8887

I heard he smells like farts

Must mean we are trading up for Caleb. We don’t have anyone that comps to him

I was really hoping we’d take a later round qb, maybe Milton or Jordan Travis or Pratt or Hartman, but with today’s signing, that seems less likely.

I wasn’t trying to bring Maye down a peg. The poster asked if there was ever a player that Maye played with that had been drafted in the first 3 rounds, so I answered his question. I’m confused on how you saw that as an attack against Maye?

ACC defense is single ply soft, especially since if you remove Florida State. FSU had playmakers on d but UNC hasn’t played them for the last 2 years.

I agree that Maye definitely had the weaker team around himself, but he also played much weaker competition. I’m not sure how easy it would be to take both of these into account to be able to decide who had it the hardest. I wish we got to see Drake play Florida State.

I can get behind taking him at #2. Though I think a trade back 1 spot to NE should be able to be made if they really like Drake or Jayden. 0.17-0.25 you get to see Drake do his Jayden Daniels impression

He might fall past the 3rd, but a lot of people have him going in the 3rd. UNC has a pretty good TE as well but I don’t think he declared

I’m all for JJ. I love the way he moves in the pocket. I hope we can trade back 1 spot and get him while adding a third in this and next years draft. Id be happy with the other guys as well.

Maye had an all American running back, 1 receiver took in the 3rd last year and another going in the 3rd this year.

I really like the way JJ moves in the pocket.

Take Command had an interesting show. Sounds as if both Craig and Logan are higher on both JJ and Jayden than Maye.

Yep, we need the entire Michigan backfield. Lol

I’ve watched a lot of Jayden, he will read the entire field sometimes and throw an accurate pass to his 4th option, on time, and accurately. I’m not sure where the 1 read and take off stuff comes from. I think he is the best processor coming in this years class. He consistently finds the most open man. And according to Jon Kiem, there are plenty of NFL guys that feel the same way.

No, they drank to much water

I was hoping we could trade down with the pats and get JJ, Drake, or Jayden there and pick up an extra pick or 2. But that’s only because I’d be happy with any of the top 4 guys, I’d be ok with a trade way down for a tackle if it were possible to land Bo nix in the second round. I’m happy with whatever the GM decides, for the first time in a long time, I think we’ve got the right people running the organization. Penix injury history concerns me a little, but I’d be ok with a starting left tackle in the first and Penix in the second as well, as long as we get a great haul of picks. But what I want most and still hopeful for is Caleb.

It does seem like we are set up for some “I told you so’s” if whoever we pick doesn’t pan out, though that kind of thing seems to always happen in qb conversations around every team, in every outlet, from the biggest of sports talk shows, to the niche message boards. Hopefully when it inevitably does happen it’ll all be in good fun. I would hope that no matter who the qb is, we will all continue to cheer for the team. I do know that if our new qb starts playing like Howell did the second half of last season, I probably won’t be to happy. Lol

Luvu looks like Jimmy USO. Yeet

I’ve watched enough film of JD, and on top of that, Keim reported that teams really like Jayden’s processing. Keim just doesn’t make up stuff like this Jon Kiem said teams really like Jayden as a processer of the field, I’ll take his word over yours

I agree. JD is really good at diagnosing defenses pre snap, he was asked to do this almost every play, including the RO/RPO type stuff. He also gets through his progressions fast.

I was leaning Maye yesterday, then last night I was thinking to myself, it’s the 4th quarter of a close game, who do I want with the ball in their hands? Maye or McCarthy? I wanted McCarthy. I wanted Jayden. Why you might ask? I just got done watching the Maye pick 6 vs Clemson. It was eerily similar to the pick Sam Howell threw against the pats this year.

I love the WR signing. He will get us some 1st downs for sure. Wahoowaa

I’m still hopeful we find a way to land him. He would make it “cool” to be a commanders fan for the younger generation. And if he plays well, that’ll be good enough to win us older guys over.

This is true, so many times he drifts right to where the pressure is coming from. Sam did this a lot as well. It’s my biggest worry when it comes to Maye. Sam got to ride the pine for a whole year and it never got better. Hopefully if Maye is the guy it will get resolved. Right now I have Maye slightly ahead of McCarthy but, McCarthy is just as good of a runner if not a little better, definitely a little more wiggle, not as big of an arm but close enough, and doesn’t have the same mechanical flaws that Maye has. I’d say he is a great piece of clay to mold as well.

Maye didn’t run because he drank a lot of water!!! On a serious note, I think we are in a great position here, we will have our pick of 3 outstanding qb prospects, maybe 4 if some funny business goes on with Caleb. Caleb would be my first choice, but out of the next three my order seems to change day by day. After watching the review I posted yesterday, im leaning Maye, but it’ll probably be Daniels or McCarthy at some point again. There is just so much to like, but all have their own issues as well.