Morrison J

Members
  • Content Count

    2,479
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Morrison J

  1. Wow Smith wasnt great last year by any means but to say Haskins will be better right from the start is extremely optimistic. If he's good enough to beat out Keenum/McCoy in camp we should be pleasantly surprised. If he comes in and performs as well as Smith off the bat we've got an absolute steal. Let's reign in expectations a bit here before we get too carried away. Also Haskins is afraid to throw the ball in tight windows a lot too, watch the tape. He's no gunslinger.
  2. Taking sacks isn't really the problem it's getting pressured to the point his mechanics go out the window and his throws miss their targets.
  3. I've watched pretty much all his interviews including that one. He comes across as a high IQ guy in general. What he does pre-snap is even at a much higher level than 95% of prospects coming out too and how he goes through his progressions is very impressive. I do think when he drops deeper and faces longer developing plays the results can be a bit dicey but I'm probably nit-picking a bit there. Think we can all agree he's at his best in the quick game when he's passing in rhythm. Keep the pocket clean and the passes quick and he's golden. That to me is more Smith than Ben, thats all I'm saying.
  4. Haskins does not have the athleticism or poise on tape to evade defenders though. Agree with that. Alex Smith does the same thing pretty well! Both high IQ players as I mentioned before as a similarity between the two. They read the field really well, just hesitate to pull the trigger. Sounds much more like Smith than Ben to me again tbh. Quick short throws, get him in a rhythm and he's looking good. Any clearer why I think there's much more Smith to him than there is Big Ben yet?
  5. Ok maybe we disagree on how we see Big Ben more than anything. I see Ben as a guy who's at his best when the play breaks down and he has to go onto his second/third/fourth read. A guy that has extreme poise in the pocket and the ability to evade pass rushers with considerable easy. I don't see that style of QB in Haskins at all. If we go back to my initial post I said the difference between Haskins and Smith is the athleticism. So I know Smith obviously uses his legs more. I'm talking about their mentality as QB's. Both are safety first and don't feel comfortable throwing into tight windows or 50/50 deep balls. That couldn't be further from how I'd describe Big Ben. Marino threw into tight windows and threw deep without hesitation. Not much of a comp between him and Haskins imo.
  6. It's not skill set I'm talking though. it's style of QB and mentality more than anything. He's much more safety first (ie like Alex Smith) than he is gunslinger (ie Big Ben). No idea why people find that fact so crazy.
  7. Doesn't bother what others see, we all have our own opinions but I've genuinely seen more Alex Smith comps than Ben. Can you make some sort of list of what Haskins and Ben have in common? You think they attack teams in a similar way? How? Haskins is a safety first QB, Big Ben really couldn't be much further from that. No problem. The tape doesn't lie when you watch it. There are things that excite me with Haskins, don't get me wrong. Loads of it coachable too. I'd just advise we stay somewhat grounded. He's got a tonne load of flaws than need ironing out and Snyder is going to want him starting week 1 with a leaky interior O-Line in front of him. There's gonna be a lot of growing pains.
  8. TOO MUCH AIR. The other thing that Big Ben does better at is that his mechanics don't fall apart like Haskins' does. Ben can find the safe area of the pocket, plant his feet and find his target (or he has the natural touch to find his receiver on the fly anyway). Haskins doesn't have the feet/poise when hurried and his mechanics take a hit as a result (see last two videos) haskins2.mp4 haskins3.mp4 haskins4.mp4 Another example of his mechanics going to pot when he feels pressure. This time a mid range throw. haskins5.mp4 haskins7.mp4
  9. Don't get me wrong I'm not concerned by his arm strength at all. I'm just saying in comparison to a Big Ben it's not at that level of natural arm strength. Feel like Haskins had one Big Ben-esque play in his entire career and people have seen that, his big upper body and concluded that he's like Big Ben. Not the case at all. This play is an outlier. Big Ben does this numerous times a game, remember that. haskins.mp4
  10. I'm just obviously watching a completely different prospect to what you are tbh. Not saying Haskins and Smith are identical by any means but there are loads of comparisons. Both are clearly smart guys who can read the field. Both don't throw deep downfield with any regularity and have accuracy issues when they do. Both excel when throwing at medium range. Both lack poise in the pocket when the only options they have are deep balls or balls put into tight windows. Both tend to come undone when pressured down the middle (Haskins more so than Smith though). The big difference is that Smith is a far better athlete and can use his legs to get himself out of bother. Haskins doesn't have that athleticism. Similarities between Haskins and Big Ben? **** all bar their body types tbh. They don't play a similar style at all. Haskins definitely does not have a canon growing out of his shoulder. Decent zip on medium range throws but theres loads of times on his tape where he gets way too much air under his vertical throws. He's not a natural big armed, deep thrower from the pocket like Big Ben for example. No way.
  11. I described Haskins in the draft thread as Alex Smith if Alex Smith didn't have his mobility to draw on. Both are hesitant to throw into tight windows or to throw deep. Neither are the type to carve up defenses with their arm. Haskins doesn't really possess any of the tools that makes Ben great at all.
  12. He's much more Alex Smith than he is Big Ben. Big Ben can throw deep, is elusive in the pocket and is comfortable under pressure. Haskins has none of those traits as of yet. Honestly, the only thing he has in common with Ben is body type really.
  13. Jay is a really bad liar lol WATCH LIVE_ Redskins HC Jay Gruden speaks to the media following the first round of the _NFLDraft 10˸17 - 10˸23 (tSWTBLoiFik).mp4
  14. Lot of my guys trending up but plenty trending down too
  15. Happy with the Jets haul. Brian Burns, DE, FSU N'Keal Harry, WR, Arizona St. Dru Samia, OL, Oklahoma Charles Omenihu, DL, Texas Renell Wren, DL, Arizona State Mark Fields, CB, Clemson Emeke Egbule, LB, Houston Penny Hart, WR, Georgia St. Big thanks to @goskins10 and @Skinsinparadise
  16. Two guys available that are sticking out on my board as insane value. Neither in big positions of need but I may take one of them. The New York Jets select Penny Hart, WR, Georgia State. His size obviously a concern but can be a really good slot receiver imo. Nice insurance for the injury prone Crowder.
  17. The New York Jets select Emeke Egbule, LB, Houston @actorguy1 OTC
  18. The New York Jets select Mark Fields, CB, Clemson
  19. He's definitely got the speed and measurables but I don't see a guy who knows how to use them to play the position tbh. Gets bullied a lot given his size. I always love watching the tape on the CB's coming out but this years class has left me a bit cold tbh. All of them have their flaws.
  20. The New York Jets select Renell Wren, DT, Arizona State
  21. The New York Jets select Charles Omenihu, DL, Texas @tibbidoe OTC
  22. Jets select Dru Samia - OG - Oklahoma @tibbidoe OTC
  23. I think we're getting fleeced giving up #15 given we lose a year of his contact and he didn't light the place up in his first year. I am however very worried if we pass on Rosen that we'll force a QB at #15 instead and take a Lock for example who imo isnt good at all and an even bigger overpay. I loved Rosen coming out last year and had him and Darnold pretty much neck and neck behind Mayfield for my top 3. Think Rosen is probably better than any QB in the draft this year personally. So if we did give up #15 I could probably talk myself into it being an ok deal. I do think Kevin Sheehan is right though that if there's one thing Bruce is decent at it's finding value through haggling. I reckon we give a 2nd and a 4th or something like that which I'd be ecstatic with.