2012: Trade it all for the #1 pick(Probably Luck), even 2013 picks if needed?

I would say most would feel that Rex is nothing more than a stop gap. For every good play he may make, he will make a bad play. The Skins long term success will be tied to some future QB.

2012 could be that time when we decide to invest in a future QB.

The consensus is Andrew Luck will be the #1 QB. If the season plays out like most think it will, we should be drafting anywhere from 10-20.

My poll question: Would you trade all your picks and even 2013 picks if need for the #1 pick?

No. Absolutely not. We have shown we can win with Rex. One bad game doesn't mean the world is crashing.

I have said it since the last game of last year, absolutley

No. Absolutely not. We have shown we can win with Rex. One bad game doesn't mean the world is crashing.

Shown we can win with Rex?

Win "what" exactly?

For the last time, there are other QB's in the next draft other than Luck that can play.

The team with that pick will never trade it. When Luck becomes a great QB, they will be crusified. I don't see any team trading the chance to draft Luck.

Luck, Barkley etc.

Gotta get a franchise QB.

I do recognize the need for that franchise QB. ASF- the Atlanta one; can post all the damn stats he wants. Rex is nothing more than a stop gap. He's a mediocre QB and nothing will change that.

I noticed in SHF thread that besides him, they are several people who are willing to trade all of 2012 and even 2013 to get the right for the number #1 pick and draft Andrew Luck. I would not do that.

No one player is worth that. Especially for a team still with many needs. They will be other QBS in the draft and if Shanny/Bruce feel they need to trade up for a QB; there will be QBs available lower where it won't cost as much to move up.

No, I'm not giving up on 2011. Just seeing the needs this team will have next year. I wasn't buying into Art's 4-0 post because I felt then and still do this is a .500 team. One big reason is Rex. If my preseason prediction holds true; Rex would be

benched after the Iggles game. We will see.

Yeah 6-10 and 8-8 records have been killing us. We need a real QB. 2 wins may not be able to land us luck at this point. We would need to drop all the rest of our games to have a chance.

On one hand, I don't really want to trade future 1st round picks for Luck, but if there's a QB there that Shanahan believes in I'm all for us trading up to get him.

- Andrew Luck

- Matt Barkley

- Landry Jones

- Nick Foles

- Kirk Cousins

- Ryan Lindley

- Robert Griffin III

- Kellen Moore

I think we can get a really good rookie QB without trading at all.

No chance bc if he ends up being anything short of manning or Brady we completely screwed ourselves for a looooooong time. I think kellen Moore is going to end up being really good and would be available for much less draft picks

- Andrew Luck

- Matt Barkley

- Landry Jones

- Nick Foles

- Kirk Cousins

- Ryan Lindley

- Robert Griffin III

- Kellen Moore

I think we can get a really good rookie QB without trading at all.

Depends on where we're picking.

And fwiw, some those QBs on your list aren't franchise caliber imo.

If you honestly believe that trading entire drafts away for Andrew Luck is the answer then you probably watch way too much college football and pay way too little attention to the NFL offseason. It's just a terrible idea.

Which is why you're typing this and not sure in charge of making the decisions.

NO.

I highly doubt the team in position to draft Luck will take any deal. You could offer them 1st rounders for the next four years and they will reject it. The only way it would be possible to trade up for Luck is if a team that doesn't need a QB has the 1st overall pick. The Colts, Seahawks and Dolphins will definitely take Luck. They will turn down any trade.

Depends on where we're picking.

And fwiw, some those QBs on your list aren't franchise caliber imo.

I'd bet big money if over the years if I had put Big Ben, Flacco, Freeman and Schaub on that list. Most would say exactly that.

What is a franchise QB anymore? We just lost to an undrafted guy last night.

don't sleep on Robert Griffin III.

I'd bet big money if over the years if I had put Big Ben, Flacco, Freeman and Schaub on that list. Most would say exactly that.

What is a franchise QB anymore? We just lost to an undrafted guy last night.

I'm not familiar with every QB on your list but Kellen Moore weighs less than Santana Moss. I don't see him QBing in the NFL.

Vinny, is that you?

Oh it isn't? You don't run the team anymore?

That's good. Cause only idiots like you STILL think trading away draft picks is a good idea.

Im about 100% sure that if the rams was to get the 1st overall pick, they would trade out of it. They already have sam bradford, why would they take luck?!! If it WAS the rams, than you make one heckuva deal and see if you can land it. If the shanaplan is to get him by every means necessary, ill be on board. Even if i dont think it was necessarily necessary.

I'm not familiar with every QB on your list but Kellen Moore weighs less than Santana Moss. I don't see him QBing in the NFL.

Is luck the best guy? Yes. Is he worth spending a lot to get? I don't know. Really....If we could trade Danny Smith, DeAngelo Hall, our 1st and 2nd rounders....I might do it. But the odds are he would cost a lot more for some team with the worst record.

From all the college football stuff I've been reading, the QB class of '12 is much better than the one that just happened. MUCH MUCH better.

If the Redskins dedicate themselves to have the best OL in the NFL with a good running game, you can plug in a rookie and gameplan to let him learn on the job. If I am Bruce Allen, I am looking at the OL and wondering how I can improve every single spot all the time. If you can protect a QB like we did with #11 back in the 90's.....you can afford to develop a guy while playing him.

Damn NOOOOOO!! There's plenty of good QBs. you don't trade all your picks. Have we learned anything from the past?

terrible idea. we need to have another solid offseason like we did this year and concentrate on drafting a QB and building up our O-Line