Redskins 2011 QB vs the 2011 Rookies Class- Who will have more success?

[darrelgreenie]

Which QB from the pole choices will have the most statistically productive 2011 season?

[squatch66]

i voted for whomever mike/kyle put under center. beck and grossman have had time in the system and the rookies are going to be learning theirs on the fly. lots more growing pains for them then our guys.

[bulldog]

Since John Beck is as intelligent as Bob Griese, as nimble as Roger Stauback, a leader in the mold of Joe Montana and a high morals guy like Peyton - how can any of us pick any other candidate? :laugh:

If Beck had not gone on that Mormon mission he would have at least 1 or 2 Super Bowl rings by now, probably............

[Gibbs Hog Heaven]

I backed Locker ever since we lost out on Bradford, and still firmly believe he'd be here now if TN hadn't interfered. Might as well see this through.

Jake Locker.

Hail.

[Hitman21ST]

Save maybe for Ponder, the Skins appear to have the best QB support staff that could help out the stats (RB/TE/WR) out of the options. I voted for the Skins because whoever we start is going to have experience in the system, and a quality supporting cast.

[Gibbs Hog Heaven]

Save maybe for Ponder, the Skins appear to have the best QB support staff that could help out the stats (RB/TE/WR) out of the options. I voted for the Skins because whoever we start is going to have experience in the system, and a quality supporting cast.

:secret: With all of the above, and Kyles pass happy offense, I actually think it's a no brainer Beck will put up better #'s than the rooks.

But I started with Locker, so I'm going down with him. :redpunch:

Hail.

[MattFancy]

I think our guy be default since there is no guarantee that any of the rookies start this year. Especially with not much time before preseason games.

[Chump Bailey]

Gotta go with Beck here.

I do love me some lamp though.

[wilburmarshall]

Rookies are going to look terrible this year.

[skinfan2k]

Cam Newton will not face a sophomore slump in fact i see something more from him

[SuperBash]

Beck was pretty popular here haha

[Bibby]

Lamp had better statistics at QB than Beck.

[kiingspadee]

I will say Cam Newton

[Gibbs Hog Heaven]

I will say Cam Newton

Going out on a limb there huh?

Hail.

[XEL]

Beck was pretty popular here haha

I vouched for the guy so much.. and ended up disappointed in him myself.. haha :/

[Commander -JB-]

Rex Grossman > John Beck. And it ain't close. Now THATS saying something.

[kiingspadee]

Going out on a limb there huh?

Hail.

Yeah I don't like the guy but something tells me he is going to break some records...maybe even Manning's (Peyton) rookie passing record....possibly a rushing TD QB record

[pjfootballer]

I love lamp....I really do.