wit33

He's an exceptional runner and should have been utilized more – a budget version of Josh Allen. It's criminal that this aspect wasn't highlighted by EB. At the very least, it could have been employed in critical situations like red zone plays and third downs.

Such disrespect lol Greg Roman is acknowledged as a savant when it comes to the run game. He faces criticism because Kaepernick, Tyrod Taylor, and Lamar Jackson didn't excel as passers in his offense. Best of luck passing for 4500 plus yards with that array of names. It's worth noting he worked with Jackson and Kaepernick when they were still early in their careers. EB comparison is off base lol

Overrated are the overhyped expectations of average offensive coordinators that were m often coupled with elite quarterbacks. Instead, it's crucial to thoroughly search the coaching market for qualities of excellence, whether on offense or defense. The front office should then focus on securing the next elite quarterback. I'm open to an elite defensive coordinator capable of consistently providing the defense with a chance to compete against top-tier quarterbacks year after year. Not that I’m against an elite offensive mind either.

What factors do you think contribute to the clear divergence in their impacts this season?

The truth is, achieving elite success in American professional sports is exceedingly challenging and often involves an element of luck. However, having skilled and intelligent individuals working towards that goal significantly improves the chances of hitting that elite window. Alternatively, there's the Bengals' approach: drafting Burrow.

Are you saying in terms of his athleticism?

Bill’s built different, norms don’t apply. I’m starved for elite coaching. I mostly agree with your points. Front office personnel often ride the wave of success without clear insights into their individual contributions. Personally, I’m biased towards the Ravens’ approach, particularly their handling of the QB position. I believe there’s a significant competitive edge in having an elite dual-threat QB. If Washington can assemble a top-notch front office, a strong defensive coach, and acquire someone like Greg Roman, pairing them with a talent like Jayden Daniels or making a trade for Murray/Fields, it could bring substantial value. Admittedly, it’s a lot of projection and a long shot, but it’s an intriguing possibility. The championship teams in the earlier years were dominantly led by their defensive prowess and were considered juggernauts. I hear you though, his last three years without Brady haven’t done much to support my position. I want elite people and he qualifies. The age thing doesn’t bother me, Bill isn’t built like the lames some may attempt to compare him to.

Must find elite some place. He remains elite on the defensive side of the ball. If that’s an option I’m okay with it. I like the Raven poaching model put out there myself.

Reviewing box scores from the early stages of Brady’s career, especially in playoff games, and seeking insights from opposing quarterbacks about how they credit his performance could shed light on the dynamics between great coaching and a great quarterback. They both were great and the credit flowed either direction game to game. Even on the offensive side Bill was ahead of his time with the spread offense and quick pass game—that doesn’t happen without his fingerprints on it whether you consider a defensive coach only.

Feel like I could play LT for the situation you described above.

While it’s not an uncommon situation, I’m waiting for the overhaul before speculating on the team’s decisions regarding the talented players. My inclination is to retain Allen and Payne; I believe they can lead a defensive resurgence with excellent coaching, potentially becoming one of the league’s best tandems in the coming years. If they are positive influences in the locker room and wish to stay, investing in them financially while aiming for the playoffs next year seems prudent. The new regime, whether it’s labeled as a rebuild or something else, should set reaching the playoffs as the immediate goal. The top players currently on the roster fit in this window. Must keep great talent much more than you don’t.

New beginnings. Those ties are the past. Good luck to Wentz, he was a good soldier while here, but was fried mentally.

Embracing an elite dual-threat option requires full organizational support. It’s crucial to cultivate a succession plan of dual-threat players behind the starting quarterback and strategically draft personnel to bolster support for the dual-threat QB. A wholehearted commitment is necessary; a halfway approach won’t suffice. I’m not interested in a dual-threat QB scenario without full commitment. We shouldn’t aim to mold or transform them into something they’re not.

Let's leave it up to Mike Macdonald or Bill B to determine who stays on that side of the ball. A solid rebound season for the defense could be led by Payne and Allen. When it comes to allocating funds, investing in two guys you're familiar with might be the way to go. Considering Allen's age and the possibility that he might prefer to move on, it might be more prudent to part ways with him. This move would eliminate any potential resistance to the new regime's plans.

You can pick up David Carr next year to do that

After around 10 weeks, most people started believing he should resume as the starter next season. Kevin Sheehan conducted a poll around that time, and an overwhelming 90% of the voters supported his return as the starter. He experienced enough success to warrant the majority of fans feeling he should be back. However, where the team fell short (IMO) was not fully utilizing his running ability, especially in crucial scenarios like 3rd and shorts, the red zone, or goal-to-go situations. Bummer this side of his game wasn’t utilized to help develop him.

Totally get your point. Upon reflection, I realize my comment might’ve fueled that vibe. I take full accountability for that and I’m responsible for my part in it. I do find banter enjoyable. Jayden Daniels here we come! I like dual threat QBs. Avatar wasn’t my choice, do you remember who changed it without my permission 10 or so years ago? Lol 😂 I do appreciate the board and imagine there’s a lot that goes behind the scenes to keep it afloat. Thank you!

This stance doesn't really catch me off guard. Your efforts to provoke won't stir things up this time. I respect the board and like exchanging thoughts, even if we don't see eye to eye. Why does this particular issue get under your skin? 😄

Can’t wait to draft a QB with a new regime filled responsibility and accountability versus excuse making filling these boards to support ones opinions.

Waiting until later in the draft to challenge Howell would be a missed opportunity if Washington secures a top 3-4 pick. Drafting a talented player with elite traits could be the key to pushing for the playoffs next year and working to build a contender. As I always mention, an elite dual-threat QB tends to offer the quickest and safest path to early success. That's why I'm intrigued by Daniels, but it's crucial that he also possesses outstanding intangible qualities. Hortiz Macdonald Roman + Daniels = 11 win season year 1

I'd be surprised if they opt for Wilson. As long as they secure a top 5 pick, they'll have the chance to inject a significant amount of excitement into the fan base by bringing in a fresh, young QB, alongside an entirely new front office and coaching staff.

Not saying you have to or should jump on it, but now might be the perfect time to grab Wilson. His value's probably dropped significantly, and he might be more open to embracing that dual-threat QB style again. Only reason you'd want him as your main guy is if he's all in on rushing for 600 yards in a season. That's the kind of play that brings the flow and rhythm needed to compete with the other QBs ranked around 6-20 or so. Most likely he’s cooked though. Can’t imagine he gets anything more than $10-15mil—fascinated to see what he gets if released in the open market, might be less than that even.

Too early. Seems like Justin Fields is really finding his groove in the latter half of the season, according to reports. Snagging him as a buy-low option could be smart, especially if he’s matched with a run-savvy OC like Greg Roman. But hey, I’d rather go for a QB with five solid years of control and a budget-friendly deal, especially if they’re a super athletic option.

I might have come on a bit too strong there, I'll admit. Truth is, I don't know a whole lot about the other two, aside from catching glimpses of their 10-15 minutes of highlights. Personally, I always tend to favor the exceptional athlete at the QB position, especially those with a first-round type grade—those guys don't often turn out to be busts. In my observation, the success rate of supremely athletic dual-threat quarterbacks in the first and second rounds seems higher compared to others. I don't have specific stats to back this, but that's just been my general impression over the last 10-15 years or so. There's a silver lining in knowing you can build an elite running game. Although, I have to admit, this aspect seems to be losing some value as the league trends towards greater athleticism at the quarterback position. Hits Cam Newton Lamar Jackson Josh Allen Jalen Hurts Kyler Murray Deshaun Watson Misses Mariota Tebow RG3

If the personality checks out, taking the safer route and drafting Daniels seems logical. It's a safe move as, from day one, you'd have a solid foundation to build a top rushing attack around year 1 on a rookie contract.