wit33

Truthfully, not many QBs secure Super Bowls, and I find it to be a somewhat lazy metric. However, in today's game where many quarterbacks can run, Purdy's three second-half runs proved to be game-changers, setting him apart from Goff.

I notice impressive twitch and agility in J. Daniels, not quite elite like Jackson, but not too far off. Early on, I hesitate to compare him to RG3 in terms of running, as RG3 lacked the quick movements and lateral agility. Daniels excels at avoiding hits near the sideline, but shows hesitancy when navigating between or near the hashes, lacking the ease of sliding and finding open spaces in the middle of the field. I wouldn't be surprised if Daniels' short-area speed measurements are on par with or close to Jackson's. Indeed, I've been on this tangent for a decade emphasizing the value of an elite dual-threat player. However, the league's increasing athleticism at that position has somewhat diminished the value of such players. It's noteworthy that elite dual-threat individuals drafted in the first round seldom disappoint.

Ron fits being a coordinator—Could see him crush it in this role. Be in the background and worry about connecting with 20-30 defensive players and that be it.

The gravy train seems to be ending for these mediocre QBs. Kudos to Mike McDaniel for his bold approach, having the confidence to generate 30 TDs and 4500 yards without shelling out exorbitant money for this tier of QB. High salaries paid to QBs is one the biggest NFL heists of the last 15 years. This is an offensive head coach (Mike McDaniel) potentially providing elite level returns if he can generate similar offensive production with a rookie or modestly paid veteran. Why wouldn’t you get Ryan Tannenhill for $10-12mil. The weakest move is for an offensive coach to spend ridiculous money on a mediocre QB to secure average returns. Fascinated to see how hat happens with Jordan Love as well.

The resurgence of his leadership style in the NFL is noticeable, with Dan Campbell leading the way and the recent inclusion of Antonio Pierce. Trends in the league often follow cyclical patterns. In line with your observation, players might not immediately rally to his defense, but building genuine rapport takes time, often linked to financial rewards. It's likely that players like Wylie and Pringle, who potentially benefited financially, have a positive view of him.

Completely on board with going against the norm and bringing in a defensive coordinator (DC) who offers a potential schematic advantage in the playoffs. Macdonald demonstrated a comparable impact to that of an elite quarterback in yesterday's game against the high-flying Texans by effectively shutting them down. I support the idea of maintaining a defensive schematic edge for the next two decades while hoping to secure an elite quarterback, thereby diminishing the significance of an offensive coordinator (OC). Not suggesting that this is the sole model. I'm fully aligned with the concept that in an organization, elite leadership and intangibles reign supreme when it comes to a coach. Unlikely due to his strong personality, but if he clearly communicates that he's done as a head coach, there could be some potential value. This is contingent on Daniels being the pick for me. Greg Roman would be a stellar hire if Daniels is the pick. It's amusing how he gets criticized for being a trailblazer in the NFL, especially considering the current Ravens OC receiving all the credit.

If Jayden Daniel’s is the pick, 100% entertain it.

To this day, I'm not sure I've seen a quarterback secure the edge quite like he did before his injury. I'm not commenting on his overall ability; it's just the way he navigated in a straight line was exceptional. His track experience truly stood out on the football field – almost as if he were launching from the starting blocks in a track meet. Post injury, the edge was no longer his ally.

Not a bad connection made here by Colin: https://sports.yahoo.com/colin-cowherd-claims-bears-firing-212850287.html

Get Jay a national gig, networks are sleeping on a potential star. He’d be fantastic with Pat Mcafee

The NFL is remarkably unpredictable unless you have an elite Hall of Fame QB or Kyle Shanahan. If someone claims otherwise, their ego might be clouding their judgment. Hope Washington can become an outlier as well. Maybe Peters is that outlier!

10000% This has consistently been my argument – money, power, and the length of the contract are significant factors. It's why I never discounted Dan in negotiations, and he demonstrated that repeatedly over the years. My concern is, if a first-time coach is pursuing those aspects, it could be potentially risky. Even if he’s considering that it could be a red flag 🚩 as you like to put it. Frequently, that's the dynamic of the business. In many instances, wielding this type of power often involves securing compensation for multiple family members as well.

If the coach is aiming for complete control, I'll decline that proposition anyway. Opting for Washington over the Panthers, especially if absolute power is offered, will speak volumes about the individual. I assume the financial aspect will be comparable in both locations. Perhaps Tepper deviates from the norm and provides more than 5 years guaranteed.

To be clear, no interest in Howell. It’s January, deal with it lol

Yes indeed and 8-12 rushing tds. He doesn’t seem to align with the expectations you have for him. Not every individual fits neatly into a specific mold. Despite concerns about potential injuries this year, he remained completely injury-free throughout the entire season. Squeeze every ounce of talent out of all players, QBs included (especially while getting paid peanuts on a rookie deal—win at all costs). For him to reach his full potential his dual threat abilities needed to be featured heavily. Whats the point with a team dropping back a 6’0 foot QB and keeping him in the pocket if plenty 6’3 plus can do that—must be dynamic at his size. I disagree; with this mindset, he most likely will not rise above mediocrity. He could likely serve as a backup and situational starter for over 10 years, earning $30 million or more in his career, which does come with financial benefits. Mediocrity can change the financial landscape for future generations, and I understand that. However, as a fan, I’m selfish and indifferent to those financial considerations; I want to support a team with an all-out approach. Watch his North Carolina videos; even with limited opportunities, he demonstrated the ability to execute similar runs in the NFL. EB and Ron wiffed big time not leaning heavily into his dual threat ability.

He's an exceptional runner and should have been utilized more – a budget version of Josh Allen. It's criminal that this aspect wasn't highlighted by EB. At the very least, it could have been employed in critical situations like red zone plays and third downs.

Such disrespect lol Greg Roman is acknowledged as a savant when it comes to the run game. He faces criticism because Kaepernick, Tyrod Taylor, and Lamar Jackson didn't excel as passers in his offense. Best of luck passing for 4500 plus yards with that array of names. It's worth noting he worked with Jackson and Kaepernick when they were still early in their careers. EB comparison is off base lol

Overrated are the overhyped expectations of average offensive coordinators that were m often coupled with elite quarterbacks. Instead, it's crucial to thoroughly search the coaching market for qualities of excellence, whether on offense or defense. The front office should then focus on securing the next elite quarterback. I'm open to an elite defensive coordinator capable of consistently providing the defense with a chance to compete against top-tier quarterbacks year after year. Not that I’m against an elite offensive mind either.

What factors do you think contribute to the clear divergence in their impacts this season?

The truth is, achieving elite success in American professional sports is exceedingly challenging and often involves an element of luck. However, having skilled and intelligent individuals working towards that goal significantly improves the chances of hitting that elite window. Alternatively, there's the Bengals' approach: drafting Burrow.

Are you saying in terms of his athleticism?

Bill’s built different, norms don’t apply. I’m starved for elite coaching. I mostly agree with your points. Front office personnel often ride the wave of success without clear insights into their individual contributions. Personally, I’m biased towards the Ravens’ approach, particularly their handling of the QB position. I believe there’s a significant competitive edge in having an elite dual-threat QB. If Washington can assemble a top-notch front office, a strong defensive coach, and acquire someone like Greg Roman, pairing them with a talent like Jayden Daniels or making a trade for Murray/Fields, it could bring substantial value. Admittedly, it’s a lot of projection and a long shot, but it’s an intriguing possibility. The championship teams in the earlier years were dominantly led by their defensive prowess and were considered juggernauts. I hear you though, his last three years without Brady haven’t done much to support my position. I want elite people and he qualifies. The age thing doesn’t bother me, Bill isn’t built like the lames some may attempt to compare him to.

Must find elite some place. He remains elite on the defensive side of the ball. If that’s an option I’m okay with it. I like the Raven poaching model put out there myself.

Reviewing box scores from the early stages of Brady’s career, especially in playoff games, and seeking insights from opposing quarterbacks about how they credit his performance could shed light on the dynamics between great coaching and a great quarterback. They both were great and the credit flowed either direction game to game. Even on the offensive side Bill was ahead of his time with the spread offense and quick pass game—that doesn’t happen without his fingerprints on it whether you consider a defensive coach only.

Feel like I could play LT for the situation you described above.