Eli. Basically average Eli Manning took down arguably the 🐐 who’s ever played the game. Look at it from the voters point of view. Basically is all the above good enough for 1st ballot? I’m guessing yeah. It’s not like anyone can say it’s a fluke. These Eli led Giants took down Brady’s Pats twice. That’s with Eli making key 4th quarter drives in both games.
Rest of Eli’s career average. Still you can’t mention Brady’s Super Bowls runs without mentioning Eli beating him twice.
Disagree all you want. Two rings, Two Super Bowl MVPs against the greatest that’s ever played the game disagrees.