Why? I'm guessing you know why and are just playing devil's advocate.
That's okay, but just in case you are being sincere; I don't think most ESer's would approve, and would view it as a wasted pick, also I think it would send out the message that we might not be 100% convinced with JD.
Even if it didn't create an actual QB controversy with those involved, it would create a lot of background noise that could become a distraction.