Jump to content
Washington Football Team Logo
Extremeskins

mistertim

Members
  • Posts

    19,882
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    45

About mistertim

  • Birthday 10/19/1977

Profile Information

  • Birthdate
    10/19/1977
  • Washington Football Team Fan Since
    Since birth
  • Favorite Washington Football Team Player
    Old Skins: Darrell Green New Skins: Sean Taylor
  • Not a Washington Football Team Fan? Tell us YOUR team:
    There are no other teams. Just groups of people who wish they were the Redskins.
  • Location
    Northern VA
  • Zip Code
    20148
  • Interests
    guitar, physics, redskins, film
  • Occupation
    Network Engineer

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. Did you read @Voice_of_Reason's breakdown on here? He literally went through every single throw in games for Maye and Daniels.
  2. You literally just ignored my question in one of the most hilariously roundabout ways possible. Have you watched his tape and cutups?
  3. I think one of the operative points of @Conn's post was most other things being equal, then arm talent is a huge tie breaker and plus. IMO he pretty much went out of his way to say it wasn't the end-all-be-all for evaluating. All other things were not even close to being equal when it comes to Leaf vs. Peyton, for example.
  4. Well if Kiper said it, then we shouldn't be questioning it. 10 Times Mel Kiper Was Completely Wrong About NFL Players
  5. AT #2 overall? I'd have a third eyebrow surgically attached just so that I could raise all 3 at the same time. This is based on what, specifically? I keep seeing some people say this but they never expand on it much. IMO it's somewhat of a wash on who is more ready between those two. Daniels has cleaner and more consistent mechanics and can rely on his running ability but Maye has much more experience making NFL 2nd level tight window and anticipation throws (and he can run as well).
  6. I don't think I'd lose my mind, I'd just be really confused and would say that GMAP had better knock this pick out of the park because if he passes on Maye and Daniels at #2 overall for McCarthy and McCarthy turns out to be a JAG while one or both of those guys go on to be studs, then his job is as good as gone.
  7. Yeah it is kind of weird. It honestly makes me wonder if all of this stuff about him flying up the draft boards is largely media driven vs what the team scouts actually think. After the championship game he was, from what I saw, mostly considered as a 2nd round or maybe a fringe 1sr round guy. But then suddenly he's top 15, then he's talked about as maybe even top 10, then top 5, then #2 overall. Wut? I might be able to understand more if he'd gone into that championship game, put the team on his back, and lit it up for 400 yards and 4 TDs or something. But that game was a microcosm of most of his college career: 140 yards 0 TDs 0 INTs, lean on the run game and defense, throw a few first downs to help move the chains, and don't make any stupid mistakes. Usually a guy with limited stats will fly up the boards due to an insane level of physical potential (Josh Allen had a very underwhelming final year at Wyoming, stat-wise), but McCarthy doesn't really have that. He has an average arm, ok size, ok mobility. Just not sure what the deal is.
  8. I think one issue with that is something we've noted here when it comes to punting until 2025: that the 2025 QB class looks very weak as of now. I'm sure the Bears would be well aware of that as well.
  9. I'm sure if he's their #1 prospect they'll at least inquire. It would be silly not to. But I'd imagine the conversation would either be: "How much to trade up to 1?" "We're not trading the pick" "Ok thanks, bye" or "How much to trade up to 1?" "Well, we're leaning towards staying here, but if you really really want it, then it's three 1sts and a 2nd" "Ok thanks, bye"
  10. This whole trading up for Williams thing reminds me a lot of 2 years ago when a group of people on this board somehow managed to convince themselves that one of Deshaun Watson, Russell Wilson, or Aaron Rodgers were going to come here, even though there was no legitimate reason to believe it would happen. Then when it didn't happen and it came out that there was never even a chance, they were really disappointed and confused. I think the same thing will happen to the people insisting that we have a chance to draft Caleb Williams.
×
×
  • Create New...