Instead of a grade for each pick, I'll give an opinion on each player they took and then do a full comprehensive grade at the end.
1st Round (19th overall): Jamin Davis, LB, Kentucky - Davis isn't someone I had on my radar early, but come the last two or three weeks before the draft, I learned about him and thought they should be strongly considering him. He brings a skill set the team needs and should be an excellent fit behind an outstanding defensive line. So yes, I'm a fan of the pick. My only slight gripe is Christian Darrisaw was still available, which I wasn't expecting, and I'd have been really happy with him as well.
2nd Round (51st overall): Sam Cosmi, OT, Texas - Definitely fits another big need and there's a bit of value with this pick to me as I thought Cosmi could have gone 10 or so picks earlier. I do wonder if he's a swing tackle, guard or starter at tackle in 2021 now that they brought Charles Leno in as a free agent. Nice pick.
3rd Round (74th overall): Benjamin St-Juste, CB, Minnesota - This pick really confused me at first. I still think I'd have preferred Paulson Adebo if they wanted a corner, but it's grown on me some after reading about his Senior Bowl performance. St-Juste has size and length that really intrigues me.
3rd Round (82nd overall): Dyami Brown, WR, North Carolina - I felt this was a bit of a steal. Brown I had in the late Round 2/early Round 3 range, so I love the value. Big play threat, and there won't be major pressure on him right away given the other weapons (Scary Terry, Samuel, Gibson, Thomas) already on the roster.
4th Round (124th overall): John Bates, TE, Boise State - Still not my favorite pick two weeks later, but Chris Cooley is a fan of it, so I'll roll with it. He should bring toughness as a blocker and a big red zone target if nothing else. Not a bad pairing at tight end along with Logan Thomas.
5th Round (163rd overall): Darrick Forrest, S, Cincinnati - I like the athletic traits, production in college and the fact that he comes from a coaching staff at a program at Cincinnati that's been doing a great job of building up a program and developing players. Could provide nice depth/special teams help early. I can't dislike this pick.
6th Round (225th overall): Camaron Cheeseman, LS, Michigan - Drafting a long snapper is something I'm personally not a big fan of, especially since they gave up a 5th round pick in next year's draft to take one. But I will say I like his name, and that if I don't hear about him during games for poor long snaps, he's doing his job well.
7th Round (240th overall): William Bradley-King, DE, Baylor - No issue with trying to add some pass rushing depth this late in a draft. He's got some nice athletic traits to work with.
7th Round (246th overall): Shaka Toney, DE, Penn State - Take what I said about Bradley-King and apply it here.
7th Round (258th overall): Dax Milne, WR, BYU - Didn't test out well athletically, but he had a big 2020 in helping Zach Wilson become the #2 overall selection.
Overall Grade: B+ - I'm kind of on the fringe between a B+ and an A-, but I think because they gave up a 5th round pick next year for the purpose of drafting a long snapper, I'm docking it into the lower range. Now I do like the draft, and while a 5th rounder next year isn't exactly the end of the world, I'm not the biggest fan of giving up that resource for a long snapper. Just my two cents.