Jump to content
Washington Football Team Logo
Extremeskins

New Fight Club thread. New rules.


PleaseBlitz

Recommended Posts

Is it allowed in the rules for you to criticize my reasoning? I thought I'd go the obvious route.

Sure, I've seen "Fight Club," but I don't really get the reference.

I'm sorry if you took my response as an insult; I was truly somewhat unsure as to whether you were trying to be funny by unexpectedly stating the obvious. That's why I said "it's actually kind of funny" and put a little wink there at the end. Sorry I misunderstood you there.

Now that I know that you weren't trying to be funny there, I'll explain that I just think that the game is designed to be a way to get alot of laughs going on, not to provide serious guesses accompanied by rational arguments. It's just more fun that way and judging by all of the other proposed fights and the rationale for predicting the winner, everyone else seems to agree.

P.S. The reference was taken straight from the movie in the scene where Brad Pitt asks Norton if he could fight anybody from any time period who would he fight and Norton responds "Gandhi" (which I think is a hilarious answer). Pitt answered the same question saying he'd like to fight Lincoln.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ernest Hemmingway:

hemmingway.jpg

vs.

An old man of the sea:

Maine__00_Old_man_and_the_sea.jpg

Hemmingway's personal honor code dictates never hitting a man with glasses. Unfortunately for Hemm, the OMOTS's honor code has no similar dictate against hitting an old man, being one himself. OMOTS wins.

Elephant

elephant.jpg

vs

Rosie O'Donnell

rosie05.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hemmingway's personal honor code dictates never hitting a man with glasses. Unfortunately for Hemm, the OMOTS's honor code has no similar dictate against hitting an old man, being one himself. OMOTS wins.

Elephant

elephant.jpg

vs

Rosie O'Donnell

rosie05.jpg

Rosie - turns out they're both afraid of mice. As they try to run away, Rosie tramples the elephant to death.

Peanut Butter

peanut-butter-1.jpg

vs.

Jelly

Jelly1st.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Die Hard the mod or Die Hard the post-mod?

hmmm... you're right. Kind of like when Superman voluntarily turned in his powers and ended up getting beat up in a diner.

In that case, I'll say Die Hard the mod.

...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hmmm... you're right. Kind of like when Superman voluntarily turned in his powers and ended up getting beat up in a diner.

In that case, I'll say Die Hard the mod.

...

To hell with that - have you seen some of Die Hard's post-mod posts? He may not have the 'mod' powers anymore - but what he lost in that, he more than made up for with brutal honesty.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Peanut Butter wins, because Jelly sucks. If it had been preserves, it might have been a fair fight.

Art

-vs-

Die Hard

....

Tough to call, but this one comes down to two little known facts. 1.) Contrary to popular opinion Die Hard is not difficult to take down, and 2.) Art is a ninja.

Cowpies

dallas.jpg

vs.

Emu

emu.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dubya wins. Cuz he's a republican and he'd have a gun on him, whereas clinton would stand there trying to work out a peace treaty.

Shampoo or conditioner?

billy_madison_picture.png

Shampoo is better, it goes on first and cleans the hair, conditioner is better, it leaves the hair silky and smooth

Shampoo wins in a close match, it does the real work in the hair washing process

how's about...

Willow

willow_ufgood.jpg

or

Mickey

mickey.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Less Filling wins, b/c Miller Lite doesn't taste great at all. More precisely, it tastes like open ass.

Dr Phil

drphil.jpg

-vs-

Phil Donahue

pdonahue.jpg

Dr. Phil. I am convinced he can solve any conflict...if he were president he'd sit osama down and make him cry because he would realize that he was treated poorly as a child and that was the reason he acted out towards the world.

Now....mini Ditka vs. God...who wins?

ditka.jpg

vs.

sistine%20god.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dr. Phil. I am convinced he can solve any conflict...if he were president he'd sit osama down and make him cry because he would realize that he was treated poorly as a child and that was the reason he acted out towards the world.

Now....mini Ditka vs. God...who wins?

ditka.jpg

vs.

sistine%20god.jpg

God of course.

mr-t.gif

vs.

stallone.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...