Compare the teams (Giants vs. Redskins)

[Mister Happy]

The strength of the Giants is their offense, like the Chiefs or Seattle, except Seattle and the Chiefs probably have better offenses and defenses than the Giants.

Is the Giants offense at least better than the Redskins offense? Let's compare the players.

[Moz Wanted]

BRUNELL>MANNING

PORTIS>TIKI BARBER

MOSS>Plaxico *Spell

REDSKINS DEFFENSE>GIANTS D

STRAHAM>GRIFFIN

SHOCKEY>COOLEY

[PF Chang]

Our problem (until last week of course) was simply putting points on the board. Stupid, small things killed us in our two losses (think of the 54 yarder that was good, nullified by a false start). If the mistakes don't happen, we cruise.

Also, I'll take our O-line over theirs, to contribute to the list.

[CBMGreatOne]

Nah, I'd say it's more like

Brunell = Eli

Barber = Portis

Moss > Plax (slim margin here)

Cooley < Shockey (wider margin than the Moss/Plax)

That's all pretty incidental, and doesn't really take all that much into account, but the most important thing is:

Skins D (4th in NFL) >>>>> Giants D (31st in NFL)

[Jizmaglobin]

the Giants are over-rated.they just aren't that good if you ask me.

[Moz Wanted]

Nah, I'd say it's more like

Brunell = Eli

Barber = Portis

Moss > Plax (slim margin here)

Cooley < Shockey (wider margin than the Moss/Plax)

That's all pretty incidental, and doesn't really take all that much into account, but the most important thing is:

Skins D (4th in NFL) >>>>> Giants D (31st in NFL)

eli and brunell are not equal who has 4 ints

brunell is more dangerious rushing and passing

and tiki is not better then porits mabye in the redzone that about it

[Taylor 21]

Look at the Defenses they played. Besides Denver

[Mister Happy]

n/m..............

[Moz Wanted]

wtf y do u guys keep makeing the same threads in less then 5 min

http://www.extremeskins.com/forums/showthread.php?t=122995

[Mister Happy]

n/m..............

[No_Pressure]

Starting QB's:When I do this I will include the Bears game in all numbers even though he wasnt the starter going into it.

Brunell- 5 Games as starter(6tot.). Combined record of teams played: 21-12

Eli- 6 Games as starter. Combined record of teams:16-18

Brunell- Average rank of opposing pass defense:20.3

Eli- Average rank of opposing pass defense:20.6

Brunell- Average yards per game passing:248.6

Eli- Average yards per game passing:235.6

Brunell- Average touchdowns per game passing:2

Eli- Average touchdowns per game passing:2

Brunell- Completion percentage:58.6%

Eli- Completion percentage:52.8%

Brunell-Average yards per game when playing away:314.6

Eli- Average yards per game when playing at home:227.3

Brunell- TD/INT ratio away: 7:1

Eli- TD/INT ratio at home: 8:3

[skinsmania123]

To say the Giant's are not good is ridiculous. They beat Denver in the waning moments when we could not. Yea I know it was raining and on their turf when we lost but we turned the ball over. The Giants do not do that. In fact they have one of the lowest turnover ratio's in the league this year.

What scares me about our D is that they have given up at least one long run per game for a TD..even during the San Fran game. I am telling you it is a big problem waiting to happen in New York.

[Art]

The Giants have very nice skill position players and a QB who has moments still mixed with youthful mistakes. This is another tough test for us in that we continue to face some pretty good offenses now with five you can deem well above average in personnel and/or production.

Still, I watched the last few Giants games with Short Cuts and Manning is not consistent. He can be rattled. The Giants have played one substantially good defense and were largely handled by Dallas. Our offense has churned out positive improvement while playing generally sound defensive units. All the advantages favor us from a matchup standpoint, but, we are a team prone to beating ourselves while Coughlin is a coach who has fielded teams with historically LOW turnover numbers.

If we play cleanly, the Giants don't have a chance. If we help them out, they do.

[dawgjk9]

agreed art...nice post. i think that if we play turnover free and eliminate the b ig play defensively...we will win this one

[Dalecitymike]

When you add it all up the Redskins win by more than 7!

The Washington Redskins

Total Offense Rank 1

Total Defense Rank 3

---------------------

The New York Giants

Total Offense Rank 4

Total Defense Rank 30

----------------------

Tom Coughlin vs Joe Gibbs

---------------------------

WIN 134 | LOSS 72 | TIE 0

Joe's

-----------------------------

WIN 78 | LOSS 72 | TIE 0

Tom's

----------------------------

Eli vs Brunnell

Eli on only his 2nd year with

RAT 88.3 | YDS 1,414 | TD 12

------------------------------

Lucky 13th (halloween)

RAT 98.3 | YDS 1,492 | TD 12

Brunnell wins!

--------------------

Leading the entire NFL in week 8

REC 38 | YDS 743 | TD 5

Santana #89 Moss Enough said!

------------------------------------

CP vs Tiki

ATT 107 | YDS 483 | TD 4

Va's tiki

------------

ATT 123 | YDS 544 | TD 3

Clinton's

--------------------------------

Offensive Line Joe Bugel's Hogs now dirtbags enough said...

They will prove themselves this game!