Jump to content
Washington Football Team Logo
Extremeskins

ggarriso

Members
  • Content Count

    459
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ggarriso

  1. It really depends how much you trust this structure for scouting and college evaluation.  Assuming Burrow goes to CIN (if he doesnt you take him without any hesitation) a RG3 type trade of multiple firsts (and second(s)) over a pass rusher is a no brainer from a pure statistical value standpoint.  That said, you have to have a talent evaluation team in place who can actually land on some or most of those picks.  If your eval is trash then the team should probably just make the safe lower value move (in this hypothetical scenario) and take Young

  2. 6 minutes ago, 757SeanTaylor21 said:

    Again let's recap what I said. I said I cant fathom how you think drafting herbert is smart...beneficial to the team (passing all those way higher tier level prospects) and is a waste of a first round pick cause one first round pick Is gonna be on the bench. Right? Ok...now you say it wouldkt be hard for herbert or any other guy to come in and surpass haskins numbers (reasonable logic granted I saw major improvement and so did the coaches...and believe me I was calling haskins out early to my friends) ...so if that is the case..why would you spend ANOTHER first round pick on a qb when u can simply SIGN one that can play better. (And that's debateable...cause case wasnt all that hot neither)  that would 1) allow the investment of a first round pick to a more impact player 2) allows a first round pick to grow...

     

    Completely respect the argument, and I generally agree, I am not a huge Herbet guy  (having only watched a couple games) but I do not believe that the current solution is a good one.  I would be more inclined to bring in a savvy vet (assuming Alex cant go) who can really compete for the job, which per leaks it sounds like that is the direction RR might head.  That said, if we were to trade down and have multiple first round or early second round picks and a QB is there who RR grades as a top level talent, I dont think we desecrate him for pulling the trigger on it.. 😃

     

  3. 11 minutes ago, 757SeanTaylor21 said:

     

    I'm not dismissive of what he sees in herbert...I dont even know him outside of his name...haven't bothered to watch him. I'm dismissive of the idea that this would be a good thing which was highlighted by me going on my mini tangent on no matter what its not a good idea. Lol. 

     

    Respectfully, you kind of are dismissive when you use language like "Just go bro" (whatever that means), followed by text dripping with condescension.  Anyone who has looked at the Redskins QB with a objective eye has major doubts about his ability to compete in the NFL, and the OP likes what he sees in a (slightly) less touted college QB.  Based on the raw numbers the Redskins QB posted last year, it wont be too hard for Herbert or any of these other guys to top him and obviously there are lots of people with major concerns about his intangibles.

    • Like 1
  4. 4 hours ago, Pick6 said:


    So clearly you are not a fan of Haskins. What could Haskins do to win you over? Or are you one of those not a fan, never will be? 

     

    Thats correct - I dont think hes the answer and I dont like any of his intangibles.  I think the big reason he had alot of detractors is that he is the pinnacle of Danny meddling.  It is well known that Jay and the talent team did not have him graded as a first round but were overruled by the FO, the placated by giving up this years #2 to get Sweat.  Then he comes in and, honestly, made a fool of himself on many occasions (too many to document) and had very very well documented commitment issues (again signaling entitlement).  

    Im a hard sell on the guy at this point, but a quiet camp (from an incident standpoint) and a productive 2020 where we see quality QB play and most of all true grit and heart, I could be turned.

  5. 49 minutes ago, CowboyKillerz said:

    . I fully expect to read an agenda riddled post full of incompetence.

     

    Respectfully, just facts and stats - you can wrap them with as many excuses as you like, but they are indisputable and the ultimate measure of logic.  simba was at the bottom of basically every measurable statistic for a QB in the NFL, almost off the charts bad in several.  Below Daniel Jones, below Minshew Mania, below almost any other QB that started a game.  By all accounts this pick came directly from the owner who has gotten exactly zero right in his entire NFL ownership career, what makes anyone think he got this right?  Oh, and we crippled ourselves in this draft to do it because he had to appease Jay who wanted to draft Sweat, who is also looking like he may not pan out as a first round level talent. 

     

    Honestly, does ANYONE think if the Redskins GM (....) offered DH for DJ straight up to the Giants tomorrow they would accept -  of course not!

     

    • Haha 2
  6. 8 hours ago, hatchetwound said:

    Giants: Might be the closest to us with a rookie QB, but honestly, Haskins has looked better

     

    ????  I wish that were the case but thats just an inaccurate statement.  Daniel Jones more than doubled "simba" total QBR at a paltry 53.6 over 26.4 - DJ threw twice the # of touchdowns to interceptions (24/12) while dannys boy "simba" went even (which is horrendous in todays NFL) (7/7).  Giants looks like they could have someone that could develop into a serviceable starter and we have a project with huge question marks on heart, commitment, and ability to process the NFL game.   Give 30 other teams the choice between the two and 30 teams take Jones, and its not even close.

     

     

    • Like 1
    • Confused 1
  7. 26 minutes ago, RandyHolt said:

    I don't want Montae back. Between the fighting and dying I think we have seen enough.  Yes someone got drugged up at his house and died and he didn't call 911, and drugs were found in his house afterwards. Oh those, those were hers rings kind of shallow after being afraid to call 911. If the league wants a drug testing policy, maybe it should include testing those after high profile drug related events occur within their homes.

     

    A fine example you set. I hope RR is made aware of all his issues.

     

    This dude is a straight human stain and I have a hard time supporting any org that employs him

     

    • Haha 1
  8. Just to parrot how good it is that Bruce Allen is gone, 49ers are gonna play for the super bowl w/ a coach we couldnt use, rams played with a coach we couldnt use and the Chiefs will play leveraging resources they fleeced us for a mediocre QB who will never play again.  bruce is the worst

     

    • Like 2
  9. 8 hours ago, JamesMadisonSkins said:

    But even if you told me we could have Simmons + 18 + 37 I’m not sure I would take that 

     

     

    I would take that in a heartbeat, Simmons could be as good or better than Young in the pros, seems to have a good demeanour and you get 18 and 37, sign me up :)

     

    • Like 1
  10. can anyone translate the JDR tweet for me?  Is he taking a dig at the previous coaching staff while molly coddling "Simba" ?  If so, I am obv not on board w/ that - throwing 50 TD's in college is irrelevant, look at the list of guys who have done it and you see several NFL busts.  He had known attitude and commitment issues last year as noted by multiple members of the coaching staff - handing him praise just because he "threw in" when he got his way (starting qb) is reinforcing bad behavior.  If we hadnt drafted a project headcase the staff would not have to play these mental games just to keep him invested, what a debacle DANNY BOY - thanks a bunch for another trash move causing organizational friction.  

     

    What I wouldnt give for Burrow.

     

    • Haha 1
    • Confused 1
  11. 21 minutes ago, SoCalSkins said:


    I argued that if KOC was the hire it was due to meddling. Albert Breer stated that Turner was the target from the beginning. Meaning Ron didn’t want KOC from the start. If he was kept it would have been because of meddling which is 100% accurate.

     

     

    spot on analysis, as usual SCS

     

    • Thanks 1
  12. 1 hour ago, SoCalSkins said:


    Nobody wants to work with Haskins in all likelihood including KOC. So we have to wait for someone really desperate... 😂

     

     

    I know this was said in jest but probably some truth to it, we know Danny is going to hamstring the staff with his chosen one and the body of work is NOT good and there are known work ethic and attitude issues.  Would I want to strap my cart to that horse knowing when it goes wrong, Danny will roll on me rather than admit his pick was a turd?  Nahhhhhhhhh

     

     

  13. 9 minutes ago, Skinsinparadise said:

    With Bruce canned and Kirk celebrating a playoff win - I would say karma exists. Class defeated sleaze.

     

    I like that !! Loved watching Kirk do his catchphrase and seeing his strong leadership and his team rally around him.  He always showed well here even with the absolutely toxic disgusting atmosphere created by our POS front office.  I LIKE THAT KIRK!

     

    • Like 2
  14. Amazing - Kirk and RG3 (I know that one is misleading) both going to the second round!! Kyle and Lefleur going to the second round!! The playoffs are littered with talent the Redskins "couldn't use"  - instead we have a pudgy prima donna who did not want to be here and put up some of the worst numbers in the NFL as well as a cap crippled by a QB who can probably never play again.  Thanks BRUCE and Danny you suck!

     

     

    • Confused 3
  15. 2 hours ago, Berggy9598 said:

    How exactly do you determine a pattern? A handful of social media posts are not a pattern of behavior. 

     

    Literally a pattern of making dumb comments either verbally, or more often, in social media - not a handful, regularly.  This just isnt the type of behavior you see winning quarterbacks engaging in

     

     

×
×
  • Create New...