I like to match up data points with tape study of that data to get context. One of the data points that I consider very important is comp % out of scrambles.
According to PFF (comp% when scrambling):

Caleb 41.8%
Maye 36.8%
Daniels 46.7%
Nix 58.6%
Penix 23.3%
McCarthy 71.4%

— Lance Zierlein (@LanceZierlein) February 14, 2024